Disagree with a review on NoLifeTilMetal or MetalMetropolis?

You should leave it as rooster.
_________________
"Happy people have no stories." —Therapy?

http://www.shocktotem.com
http://www.eyesoretimes.com
http://www.getcharocksoff.com

Metal novice Age : 16 Joined : 30 Aug 2007 Posts : 95

This is for UltMetal. This isnt a complaint, But when I was scrolling through your list of bands, I noticed that You didn't have any Tony MacAlpine (Well, nothing but M.A.R.S.). Whats up with that? Tony MacAlpine is a shred god! His albums Maximum Security and Edge of Insanity are Metal Masterpieces.

Heart of Metal Age : 18 Joined : 19 Sep 2007 Posts : 1900

I look through Ult's website a lot, and I have found about a billion grammatical errors. It's not a big deal, but come one! Hahaha.
_________________
What part of "Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn" don't you understand?

Ult's review of Possessed's "Seven Churches" could be a little better, focuses too much on the lyrics, while they are ridiculous, it's a GREAT album.

Heart of Metal Age : 35 Joined : 27 Jul 2007 Posts : 2286

I have not noticed that, infact, he seems to be pretty accurate.

U caNte SpuLe ScaUGhTT!!!!

Heart of Metal Age : 18 Joined : 19 Sep 2007 Posts : 1900

Metal novice Age : 39 Joined : 30 Jan 2008 Posts : 17

I love NLTM. Found it years ago. Came back to it recently. Amazed at how its grown. Cant say I disagree with anything but I love the Hall Of Shame. Funny stuff. My my how some people are so touchy. They're only opinions folks.

I also like how diverse this guys collection is.

Gee I wonder where he got those Beyond Fear pics from. Laughing

_________________
"James Bond has a license to kill, rockstars have a license to be outrageous. Rock is about grabbing people's attention."

-Gene Simmons

Administrator Joined : 04 Jan 2007 Posts : 7735

They are your opinions and should remain so. Don't change a thing!

My only complaint?? You've cost me $1000's of dollars!!! (Actually, you've probably saved as much because I reference your site as a starting point. If you say it's crap my search usually ends there...)

And on some reveiws where you're neither here nor there on a band at least your reasonable and calm assessment lets me know what the band is like and arms me with the knowledge I need...
_________________
I'm warning you. I'll be forced to Thrash you!

Metal master Age : 19 Joined : 28 Jan 2008 Posts : 992

To be completely honest, I agree with everything I have read so far on NoLifeTilMetal. One error I did find was that you said Neil Peart did the "rap" vocals on Roll the Bones. That was actually Geddy Lee, if I remember correctly. They just electronically enhanced his voice. As for Metal MetalMetropolis, I need to spend a little more time reading the reviews.

Guest

I've read nolifetilmetal many times over and the only review that I have ever disagreed with (as well as on all cd sites) is Motorhead's Iron Fist. I realize that you don't straight up say it's bad, but I think it deserves much more credit than it's given. Granted, it seems bland coming off of the wake of Ace of Spades and Hammersmith, but it excellently retains their Bomber era sound, with a little bit of Ace of Spades on a few tunes. I can see how it doesn't stick out like Overkill or AOS, but it's definately as good as Bomber. And, Eddie's work on that album is incredible. Such an interesting craft and dynamic to that album.

Administrator Joined : 04 Jan 2007 Posts : 7735

Iron Fist is one of the forgotten Motorhead albums. I haven't actually listened to that one in some time.

ult
_________________

Metal novice Age : 20 Joined : 19 May 2007 Posts : 35

xyz mentioned the Rush- Roll The Bones review:

Administrator Joined : 04 Jan 2007 Posts : 7735

Heart of Metal Age : 21 Joined : 20 Apr 2007 Posts : 1201

Have you heard the other Soulfly albums Ult, or just listened to the first one and gave up?

Oh, and Chris wants to know when you're gonna do the Era Vulgaris album review.
_________________
Eyesore - "There's 3 chicks here? Who? Why the hell have I been hitting on you guys this whole time when there's chicks here?"

Administrator Joined : 04 Jan 2007 Posts : 7735

Heart of Metal Age : 21 Joined : 20 Apr 2007 Posts : 1201

Administrator Joined : 04 Jan 2007 Posts : 7735

Wow! I don't recognize that at all. I don't think I have it. I'll double check, but don't recognize that cover.

ult
_________________

Heart of Metal Age : 21 Joined : 20 Apr 2007 Posts : 1201

Administrator Joined : 04 Jan 2007 Posts : 7735

I'll check for it. Do you know how long ago that was?
_________________

Heart of Metal Age : 21 Joined : 20 Apr 2007 Posts : 1201

Metal graduate Age : 21 Joined : 14 Feb 2007 Posts : 465

" I'm A Rebel, however, sounds a bit more dated and
nowhere near as good as the aforementioned discs. "Save Us" actually
sounds like a disco tune with it's funky bass lines"

I used to think that I am a rebel was a bad album, until I got a German Re-release. Now that i have it and listened to it, it sounds like a 70's glam band. It reminds me to Slade and Sweet. Even thought this is not as good as the other accept albums with UDO, it is as enjoyable as the others
_________________

For all his good looks there were scars that he took
And a lesson to be learned
Never judge lovers by a good looking covers
The story might be spurned

Administrator Joined : 04 Jan 2007 Posts : 7735

Guest

For ult. This is a stupid comment , but here goes: although I agree with 100% that Mergadeth's Countdown to Extinction is not a sellout (it's an awesome metal album) and that it is a masterwork, I find it strange that you refer to it as speed metal. Not only is most of the album low- to mid-tempo, but the fast songs (of which there are few) don't even come close to their earlier work (excluding songs like "Liar" and "Wake Up Dead").